71
edits
Talk:Does the globalization of media lead to homogenization?: Difference between revisions
Jump to navigation
Jump to search
Talk:Does the globalization of media lead to homogenization? (view source)
Revision as of 21:42, 7 January 2010
, 21:42, 7 January 2010no edit summary
No edit summary |
No edit summary |
||
| Line 18: | Line 18: | ||
1. Basic criteria | 1. Basic criteria | ||
1.1. Relevance of the subject to the general theme (High/Medium/Low)...................... | 1.1. Relevance of the subject to the general theme (High/Medium/Low).......high............... | ||
1.2. Coherence of the content with the title and thesis (High/Medium/Low)...................... | 1.2. Coherence of the content with the title and thesis (High/Medium/Low).........high (but not too)............. | ||
1.3. Quality of the content from the methodological point of view (see below) (High/Medium/Low)...................... | 1.3. Quality of the content from the methodological point of view (see below) (High/Medium/Low)........medium.............. | ||
1.4. Quality of the text from the formal point of view (see below) (High/Medium/Low)...................... | 1.4. Quality of the text from the formal point of view (see below) (High/Medium/Low).........high............. | ||
2. Summary Comments for Author(s) | 2. Summary Comments for Author(s) | ||
2.1. Contribution to theory or practice (High/Medium/Low) ...................... | 2.1. Contribution to theory or [[practice]] (High/Medium/Low) .....high................. | ||
2.2. Originality of the paper (High/Medium/Low) ...................... | 2.2. Originality of the paper (High/Medium/Low) .......medium............... | ||
2.3. Adequate references to prior and related works by other authors (High/Medium/Low) ...................... | 2.3. Adequate references to prior and related works by other authors (High/Medium/Low) ........high (but not too).............. | ||
2.4. Accurate information (Yes/No) ......................... | 2.4. Accurate information (Yes/No) .........yes................ | ||
2.5. Current information (Yes/No) ....................... | 2.5. Current information (Yes/No) ...........yes............ | ||
2.6. Methodology (Yes/No) ........................... | 2.6. Methodology (Yes/No) ............yes............... | ||
2.7. Writing style is generally (Excellent/Readable/Poor) .................... | 2.7. Writing style is generally (Excellent/Readable/Poor) ..........excellent.......... | ||
2.7.1. Paper is logically organised (Yes/No) .................... | 2.7.1. Paper is logically organised (Yes/No) ......yes.............. | ||
2.7.2. Ideas are clearly presented (Yes/No) .................... | 2.7.2. Ideas are clearly presented (Yes/No) ..........yes.......... | ||
2.8. Meets submission requirements (abstract, length, style, citation rules) (Yes/No)... | 2.8. Meets submission requirements (abstract, length, style, citation rules) (Yes/No)...yes...... | ||
3. Written Comments for Author(s) | 3. Written Comments for Author(s) | ||