Talk:Global-labor, Risk or Opportunity?: Difference between revisions

no edit summary
No edit summary
No edit summary
Line 16: Line 16:
1. Basic criteria
1. Basic criteria


1.1. Relevance of the subject to the general theme (High/Medium/Low)
1.1. Relevance of the subject to the general theme '''High'''


1.2. Coherence of the content with the title and thesis (High/Medium/Low)
1.2. Coherence of the content with the title and thesis '''High'''


1.3. Quality of the content from the methodological point of view (see below) (High/Medium/Low)
1.3. Quality of the content from the methodological point of view (see below) '''Medium'''


1.4. Quality of the text from the formal point of view (see below) (High/Medium/Low)
1.4. Quality of the text from the formal point of view (see below) '''Medium'''


2. Summary Comments for Author(s)
2. Summary Comments for Author(s)


2.1. Contribution to theory or practice (High/Medium/Low) ......................
2.1. Contribution to theory or practice '''High'''


2.2. Originality of the paper (High/Medium/Low) ......................
2.2. Originality of the paper '''High'''


2.3. Adequate references to prior and related works by other authors (High/Medium/Low) ......................
2.3. Adequate references to prior and related works by other authors '''High'''


2.4. Accurate information (Yes/No) .........................
2.4. Accurate information '''Yes'''


2.5. Current information (Yes/No) .......................
2.5. Current information '''Yes'''


2.6. Methodology (Yes/No) ...........................
2.6. Methodology '''Yes'''


2.7. Writing style is generally (Excellent/Readable/Poor) ....................
2.7. Writing style is generally '''Readable'''


2.7.1. Paper is logically organised (Yes/No) ....................
2.7.1. Paper is logically organised '''Yes'''


2.7.2. Ideas are clearly presented (Yes/No) ....................
2.7.2. Ideas are clearly presented '''Yes'''


2.8. Meets submission requirements (abstract, length, style, citation rules) (Yes/No)..........
2.8. Meets submission requirements (abstract, length, style, citation rules) '''Yes'''


3. Written Comments for Author(s)
3. Written Comments for Author(s)
Line 54: Line 54:
4.1. Publish as is
4.1. Publish as is


4.2. Acceptable with minor modifications
'''4.2. Acceptable with minor modifications'''


4.3. Might be accepted after major modifications
4.3. Might be accepted after major modifications