VCSEwiki:Peer review form for case studies: Difference between revisions

VCSEwiki:Peer review form for case studies (view source)

724 bytes added , 16:50, 26 February 2011

column for students added

445

edits

@@ Line 1: / Line 1: @@
-Used for Case study review process in 2010/2011 course
+Outline of review criteria for Case study review
 {| border=1
   | '''Criteria''' || '''Quality aspects to be considered in the case study''' || '''High/Medium/Low''' ||
@@ Line 12: / Line 12: @@
   | '''Practical relevance''' || Main goal of the case study writing is transmitting of some practical experience – was this goal fulfilled? || ||
   |-
-  | '''Focus''' || 'Core problem of the case identified   conclusions made it explicit and transferable. || ||
+  | '''Focus''' || Core problem of the case identified.
+Conclusions made it explicit and transferable.
+|| ||
   |-
   | '''Clarity''' || Logical structure: from description to generalization and posing analytical questions.
@@ Line 29: / Line 31: @@
   |-
   | '''Total (points)''' || || '''max 100''' ||
+|}
+Form for students' evaluation - just copy and paste (from editing mode), and fill in you assessment in relevant column!
+{| border=1
+ | '''Criteria''' || '''High/Medium/Low''' ||
+ |-
+ | '''Content'''|| 10 / 5 / 0 ||
+ |-
+ | '''Context''' || ||
+ |-
+ | '''Practical relevance''' || ||
+ |-
+ | '''Focus''' || ||
+ |-
+ | '''Clarity''' || ||
+ |-
+ | '''Critical approach''' || ||
+ |-
+ | '''Elaborateness (commitment) ''' || ||
+ |-
+ | '''Individual input & risk-taking ''' || ||
+ |-
+ | '''Reader's attractiveness''' || ||
+ |-
+ | '''Formal features ''' || ||
+ |-
+ | '''Total (points)''' || '''max 100''' ||
 |}