VCSEwiki:Peer review form for case studies

Criteria	Quality aspects to be considered in the case study	High/Medium/Low
Content	The content of the case study is relevant for this genre. Good resources for this type of writing – both describe the real case and provide more general reflection. Resources well used – important features selected, arguments justified on them.	10 / 5 / 0
Context	Local and global circumstances of the problem sufficiently described; general (theoretical) background outlined.
Practical relevance	Main goal of the case study writing is transmitting of some practical experience – was this goal fulfilled?
Focus	Core problem of the case identified. Conclusions made it explicit and transferable.
Clarity	Logical structure: from description to generalization and posing analytical questions. Formally coherent (paragraphs and ideas connected)
Critical approach	No bias, opposing views presented.
Elaborateness (commitment)	Sufficient length and number of resources, details elaborated.
Individual input & risk-taking	New themes, ideas, original (but justified) conclusions…
Reader's attractiveness	Did you enjoy reading the case study? To which extent?
Formal features	Structure, headlines, citation norms, language
Total (points)		max 100

Form for students' evaluation

- just copy and paste (from editing mode), and fill in you assessment in relevant column!

Criteria	High/Medium/Low
Content	10 / 5 / 0
Context
Practical relevance
Focus
Clarity
Critical approach
Elaborateness (commitment)
Individual input & risk-taking
Reader's attractiveness
Formal features
Total (points)	max 100

.....................................................................................

1. Acceptable as is

2. Acceptable with minor modifications

3. Might be accepted after major modifications

4. Unacceptable (provide reasons):

.....................................................................................